The Future of Weiss Schwarz

13 Jun

A lot of you may be wondering where I’ve been and what I’ve been doing for the last 5 months of seemingly no activity. In short, I discovered this thing called Netflix so I’ve been watching actual TV shows all day long as well as grinding in various RPGs. However, with the release of the first official English Weiss Schwarz booster box, I decided to take a little time and write about my thoughts on the future of Weiss Schwarz and it’s community.

Being the owner of a card store that mainly specializes in Weiss Schwarz and Vanguard, I try to pay close attention to how the members of these communities act towards each other as well as how the communities act towards each other. Before I begin, I want to make it clear that I’m an American and during this article I’m going to be really only talking about the future of Weiss Schwarz in America. My comments can probably extend to other areas as well but I’m writing this mainly in response to the recent changes in the American scene.

As many of you may know, English trial decks for Fate/Zero and Puella Magi Madoka Magica were released almost a year ago and following their release was a lot of discussion of how seriously Bushiroad was going to take the English side of Weiss Schwarz. There was also a Disgaea trial deck that was released a few years ago but it was never really a sign of Weiss Schwarz getting English sets because it wasn’t officially created by Bushiroad. Fast forward to where we are now: the booster box for Puella Magi Madoka Magica was released 13 days ago, Sword Art Online is officially getting an English release that is set to be released early July, and the language barrier that was stopping so many people from playing is starting to fade away. Exciting stuff! At this point you might be wondering, if everything seems to be going great so far then why exactly am I writing this article? The answer to this is that there are some concerns that I have for the future of this game and want to share my thoughts on these matters. I’ll start off with the biggest issue currently at hand.

When Bushiroad first announced that they were officially picking up English for WS, a lot of people (myself included) wondered what would become of the Japanese scene in America. I have about 13 decks that are all in Japanese so my first thought when they announced English WS was: Do I need to completely remake these in English if I want to use them in official tournaments? That would take a lot of time, effort, and money that I’m not sure I would be willing to spend. A little bit after the announcement, it was revealed on the English Weiss Schwarz website that English and Japanese cards would be allowed together. How great! Everything’s going perfectly! Or should I say, everything was going perfectly until 3 weeks ago when I received 2 e-mails from Bushiroad with links to sign my shop up for official tournaments. You may have guessed it when I said 2 e-mails, but pretty much Bushiroad decided to change their minds and sent me 1 message which was to sign up for English only tournaments and another message that was to sign up for Japanese only tournaments. A mountain of questions immediately started forming in my mind, when other card store owners started messaging me to ask if I had heard the news. We were all extremely confused and agreed that Japanese cards should be allowed with English cards in some way. We had always known that there would be 2 separate tournaments, but we were under the impression that 1 would be for English only and the other would be for both English and Japanese cards.

MADoka

Some of you may be wondering, “Why is this such a big deal?” Now keep in mind that everything I write is my own opinion and isn’t necessarily true or going to happen, but let me share my opinions on what I feel could possibly happen in the future because of this. The very idea of splitting English cards and Japanese cards implies the splitting of old players and new players. Bushiroad was hoping that the release of English WS would cause many new players to start playing and join the already existing community; however, by not allowing the 2 sides to be actively involved with each other on a competitive level, this makes one think that the competitive side of WS will never reach it’s full potential. The American scene isn’t really too competitive in the first place, but it’s definitely not because we just want to be casual players, we were just never presented a real competitive environment. Among all the players in America, I consider myself to be on the more competitive side since I used to participate in tournaments every week and have gone to some relatively large WS events; because of this, you may think that I’m biased when it comes to wanting a more competitive atmosphere. To ease your minds, I’ve asked many customers at my store (both competitive and casual) what their opinions on the competitive scene are and all of them, including the casual players, said they would love to see a more competitive environment. For the competitive players it’s a way to test their skills and play new players that they would otherwise never get the chance to play. For casual players it’s an entertaining thing to spectate and can help them learn by watching new play styles. Overall, a thriving competitive scene would help everyone learn more about Weiss Schwarz and would help grow the community. Similarly. if the old players aren’t allowed to play with the new players without having to spend time and money on new decks, it could cause a lot of old players to not really care about the new players and, although that doesn’t directly hurt anyone, it certainly doesn’t benefit anyone. It could potentially keep the old players in a stagnant state with no real reason to get any more into the game and therefore cause new players to stop playing the game since it seems like the game isn’t going anywhere.

Of course some people are alright with the division between English players and Japanese players. A lot of the new players that start playing as a result of English releases come from a long history of playing card games and therefore have a different view on card game communities than I do. You see, I was never really a card game player before I started playing WS. I was simply a college student who watched too much anime and one day walked into a store that sold Angel Beats! cards. Compared to me, people who start playing WS after Magic and Yu-Gi-Oh! might not be so trustful of others since (though I hate to say it) there are a lot of cheaters and thieves in other card games. If I had known people who cheated in card games in the past, I would definitely not trust people telling me what every single Japanese card in their deck does. Many players may think that it’s good to have an English only tournament simply so that no one could cheat by mis-translating their card. Although I do agree with this, I am still in favor of when we thought there would be 2 tournaments: 1 for English cards only and the other for Japanese and English cards. I honestly believe that that is the best format we could have with the new transition into English sets and really hope that Bushiroad eventually changes their mind.

Another concern that I have for the future of Weiss Schwarz is that we have no idea which series are going to be released first. Madoka was a pretty solid pick as the first booster box, Sword Art Online is amazingly popular among both anime lovers and regular people so that will for sure be a huge success, and Fate/Zero isn’t as popular but it definitely appeals to the players that like more action oriented and realistically drawn shows so it’s not a bad 3rd pick. What concerns me is: what will be next? I don’t want to sound like I’m talking poorly of the higher ups in Bushiroad, but I have no idea who chooses what set will be released and, for all I know, they might not really know too much about the current Anime world and what people are into at the moment. I’ve talked to some people that work in the American Bushiroad branch about my opinions and what sets to release, and time and time again I keep telling them: release Fairy Tail in English. Fairy Tail (although not as popular in Japan) is extremely popular in America and would bring so many new players in just because it’s Fairy Tail. I don’t want this to become a rant that just talks about what I want to happen or anything like that, but can you imagine what would happen if the new set was something like Phantom or CANAAN? Obviously those 2 are less popular titles in WS so it’s very unlikely that they will be released in English anytime soon, but I can see sets that are decently popular like Da Capo or Milky Holmes getting English releases; even though those 2 are relatively well known, they definitely wouldn’t entice many new people to join just by their very existence being in Weiss. Of course this is all speculation but I worry quite a bit because I’ve seen Bushiroad make some pretty questionable decisions in the past.

I don’t want anyone to start thinking badly of Bushiroad because, without them, there wouldn’t be a community in the first place! I simply want people to start thinking about what all the recent changes mean to us as players and what we must do to overcome certain obstacles. As I stated at the beginning of this article, I’m a card store owner so I try my best to observe what’s happening in the community and try to resolve and conflicts that may arise. I don’t want to see a community that gets capped at a casual level where things never really get worse but never get any better either. On that note, I’ll talk about some of the hopes I have for the future.

One thing that I have always loved about Weiss Schwarz is the fact that when I play someone new, I know that I can relate to them in some way or the other. Whether it’s the fact that we simply both like Anime, or the fact that Kanade is also their Waifu, we can probably get along at some level. I’m always happy to meet new players because I find that most of the players in the world are relatively nice and always willing to help. I feel that if this kind of community kept growing then it would keep becoming better and better. Even if things never take a more competitive turn and we become stuck in a metaphorical hole of casualness, the one thing that would keep this community alive is the fact that everyone is generally nice to everyone. One possibility that could happen in the future is that the English side actually becomes extremely popular and the Japanese side itself starts to die out. Though this isn’t exactly “good” for the current community, I would argue at the same time that it is good overall because it would mean a larger player base and more inevitable support for the English market. This possibility kind of sucks for people like my current customers and I but we if we want to keep playing we would probably adapt and simply move on. One thing that I want to remind everyone is that Bushiroad is the first company to really bring a well rounded Anime card game to America (to the best of my knowledge). Even though they were pitted against companies such as Konami and Wizards, they were able to hold their ground and that definitely says something. If anything, Bushiroad is doing something right so far and all we can do is hope that they continue to make the correct decision.

I just reread everything I wrote so far and this really comes across like a long and disorganized rant. I hope that I don’t sound like I’m angry at Bushiroad or anything like that, I simply want to express my feelings about the current events that have been happening. I mean, Bushiroad could have simply decided to never make Weiss Schwarz into English and the community would stay in a rut, forever trying to solve the mystery of the language barrier. The fact is that Bushiroad is trying to help the community, and that alone is enough for me. I still think that they should change the tournament system to have both English only tournaments and mixed tournaments, but if this never changes then we just have to move on and try to deal with whatever happens.

That’s all I have for today. I want to say thanks to everyone who’s been reading my blog despite there being no updates in a long time. When I checked my stats today I was sure that there had been no views in the last few months but, to my surprise, there were actually quite a few! Hopefully this gives me the motivation to write more and more in the future. Feel free to leave your comments and let me know what you think about the future of Weiss Schwarz.

About these ads

4 Responses to “The Future of Weiss Schwarz”

  1. Sethala September 8, 2013 at 11:55 am #

    One reason that I think the separation can be a good thing is that we don’t have all the legal cards in English yet. I had never heard of Weiss Schwarz until I saw it at GenCon this year, in English. If I learned later that I would need to import Japanese cards and get English translations of them to be competitive, because the “big cards” are not in English yet, I’d be very put off.

    What I think should happen is two tournament formats. The first is only English-released sets are legal, -but- any language cards are fine, so long as the player with the foreign cards has a single English card, either an actual card or just a printed copy, with all the rules text available for the opponent to check. That would let someone that already has a large collection of Japanese cards avoid buying the cards all over again, but would also let someone who doesn’t want to buy foreign cards be perfectly competitive and not limit their access to the card pool.

    The second format should be the normal Japanese tournament format, but again English cards should be usable.

  2. countdaryo September 11, 2013 at 4:58 am #

    AS someone who has been playing CCG/TCG for over a decade I have seen and played card games in various languages. In official Magic Tournaments (standard and otherwise) you can use any language card you can or might have at your discretion you just translations with it (AKA the English card print) just in case any questions are asked. I believe the two should be combined, and this is coming from someone who just started WS a little less than a week ago. I have an SAO TD and a booster box en-route and I am going to order the Gargantia Japanese Deck. I can work with translations and sleeve inserts I am a competitive player and have always been so since I started in Yu-Gi-Oh 13 or so years ago (longer if you include the Japanese collection I had). Trust me when I say a competitive environment would most likely increase sales of the English stock too because people would be trying to build the decks. Only thing I am not a big fan of right now is the price tag on this game because I can throw down 97 for a box of Magic but I have to throw down 75 for a box of WS which is 16 packs and roughly 380 cards less.

  3. Kudou Kun December 2, 2013 at 6:38 am #

    Sorry, this is kind of an awkward way to do this, but would you mind sending me an Email message? I’d like to ask a favor of you, but I don’t wanna ask it here out of respect. Sorryif this looks so strange >_<

  4. Taylor January 18, 2014 at 4:09 pm #

    Bushiroad should release an official list of card translations. That way, they could bring a large variety of already-published sets to the English market, without having to immediately publish English sets that they aren’t sure will sell.

    A translated card list would allow the Japanese and English community to duel without fear of cheating, and would allow English-only players to buy Japanese cards to build competitively viable decks.

    Tournaments could potentially benefit from the creation of a special group where only cards published in America (The cards can be in Japanese or English) would be allowed.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: